Hanna drives Callen to McGuire's apartment. Hanna says he will pose as a real estate agent while Callen poses as a potential buyer. They break into McGuire's apartment and hear a caller access his answering machine and erase all of the messages. They call Eric, the technician, at headquarters and ask him to get into McGuire's phone logs.

Back at the apartment, they find a picture of McGuire celebrating Fleet Week with a young girl. They find a birthday card from McGuire's niece, Emma. They take his laptop then leave. Callen sees a group of gardeners, tells them he is interested in moving in and asks them if the area is safe. Callen says that he heard a Navy officer that lived in the apartment was recently killed. The gardener says that McGuire had friends pick him up in a Blue Tahoe every day that week. Hanna sees a towncar waiting outside and chases after it. The towncar driver quickly throws his car in reverse, spins around and speeds away.

Callen and Hanna return to headquarters. They figure that the people who picked up McGuire put a bag over his head in order to prevent him from seeing where they were going. Dominic says that the only family that McGuire had was a sister who has a daughter named Emma. Kinsi volunteers Nate, the psychologist, and herself to tell her the bad news about her brother. They see that McGuire has been receiving a lot of calls lately from Bobby J, a friend of his who owns a private security company. Callen and Hanna visit Bobby J and he admits that he was in the towncar in front of McGuire's apartment. Bobby J says that he knows nothing about McGuire's kidnapping. Hanna sees Bobby loading boxes of weapons and asks him if he is planning a hunting party. Bobby J says that they are done talking.