Lee brings Allison to the home of a man named Earl Sanderson who was found shot dead while digging in his fridge. Lee says he doesn't think the case is a robbery. He says they only found a sneaker print outside the window. Allison has a vision about a man tied up in a hole. She sees Earl as he unleashes cement that buries the man. Allison says she doesn't know who killed Earl, but knows who Earl killed.

At work, Joe's coworker starts cracking up at his computer. He calls over Joe to watch a video of a man freaking out after he fails to put on a tire. They see several clips of him drop groceries out of a bag. Joe realizes that Bridgette shot the video and uploaded it online.

Allison asks Bridgette about the man, but she says she doesn't know him and just thought he was funny. Allison orders her to take the videos down. After Ariel brings in Casey, Allison realizes that Casey is actually Kyle from her dream.

Later, Joe tells Allison that Casey seemed smart and respectful. Allison says she is still worried that Ariel might get pregnant. Joe tells her that he knows her visions are unreliable when it comes to loved ones. He tells her he thinks she is just anxious. Lee calls Allison and tells her they found a match to her drawing to a man named Angelo who was reported missing in 1992.

Allison has a dream about Casey outside of Earl's house. Casey grabs a gun, puts on a hood and walks towards Earl. After she wakes up, Allison tells Joe she is positive she saw Casey. She asks him if he remembers what kind of shoes Casey was wearing since the police found a print outside Earl's window. Allison says she is going to ask Casey herself. Joe advises she wait until she gets more evidence. Joe wonders if she is finding a reason not to like Casey.

Lee and Allison meet Casey at the school and show him the picture of Earl. He says he doesn't recognize him and would like to go back to class. Lee tells Allison that he doesn't want to interrogate Casey, but Allison insists. He asks Casey where he was two nights ago. He says he was at home doing homework. Casey asks if he is in trouble. Lee asks if there is anyone who can confirm his whereabouts. He says both of his parents were away at the time. Lee asks what size shoes he wears. Allison says the footprint found at Earl's matches his shoes. Casey's mom Nancy arrives and tells Casey to wait outside. She tells Lee and Allison she knows who both of them are. Lee informs her they are following a tip about a homicide. Nancy says she can't believe they ambushed Casey without contacting her or a lawyer. She says she will contact his boss and her attorney. Nancy tells Allison to have her entire family stay away from her son. Allison says she thinks Casey is hiding something. As Casey talks to Nancy outside the door, Allison has a vision of Angelo in place of Casey.