Cal goes to a party. He introduces himself as a courier to a woman who later walks away. Gillian calls him and tells him about a case to help look for a man named Eric Masterson, who is suspected of murdering his wife. A woman sits down with Cal and introduces herself as a curator. Cal says he might be old fashioned but wants fidelity in relationships. The woman says she never strays. He rejoins the party and gets a card from a woman he was flirting with earlier. He leaves and gets into his car.

Ria goes to a house and asks a woman named Gwen if she knows where her brother Eric is. She says Eric's wife Connie was her best friend. Ria asks if there is anything else she wants to talk about, but she says nothing. Ria returns to her car and finds Eric in the backseat of the car. He figures the cops were at his house. He points a gun at her head and orders her to drive.

Cal returns to the Lightman Institute and tells a client after his investigation, he figures his wife never violated his prenuptial clause. After the clients leave, Gillian tells Cal he needs to take cases like that since he had the company buy out his ex-wife out of the company. Eric arrives with Ria as his hostage. He demands that the team prove he didn't kill his wife. He shoots and misses a man who escapes. Cal sees he is not playing around. Eric announces if the cops show up, he will start killing people. Cal says he is the owner of the institute. He suggests he go to his office where they can watch the office. As Cal leads Eric to his office, he orders Gillian not to contact the police. Gillian tells Ria to call Ben.

In the office, Cal asks Eric why he didn't go to the police if he knows who killed his wife. Eric says he knows Cal has a talent of telling who is lying. Eric asks him if he believes him when he says he didn't kill his wife. Cal says he does. He asks him who he thinks killed his wife.

Meanwhile, Ben arrives at the institute. He says it is a felony not to report a crime. Cal calls Gillian and asks her to come to his office. Gillian tells Ben that Eric will kill Cal if they don't do what Eric wants. Ben says he will hold off reporting the incident on one condition.

Gillian enters Cal's office. He asks her to interview a man named Tom McHenry who Eric suspects was having an affair with his wife. Gillian admits that Ben is there. Cal explains that Ben is a federal agent.