While riding to their destination, Gretchen asks Claire if she wants only to be her friend. Claire says she doesn't know. The girls are taken out and brought to a room with other pledges. Becky says they will go on a treasure hunt in which the winner will be allowed to sit out of hell week.

Tracy meets with Jeremy and tells him she is there with Noah and posing as his aunt. Jeremy says Noah promised his problems would go away. Jeremy admits he doesn't think he should be let out since he murdered his parents.

Matt gets angry at Sylar for sleeping with his Janice. Sylar says he can do other things to his Janice and his son Matty.

The sorority pledges realize they are in a slaughter house. Gretchen finds a puzzle on the wall above several lockers. One of the girls opens up a locker which causes fake blood to be sprayed on her face. Claire figures they should open the locker with the number corresponding to the year the sorority was found. Inside they find a bag full of supplies and split it amongst themselves.

Tracy tells Jeremy she understands what he is going through. She confesses she killed a man when she first discovered her powers. She shows him that she can turn into liquid. Tracy tells him she will get him out of there.

The sheriff says they have plenty to keep Jeremy. Another deputy reads Noah Jeremy's dark writings that he says proves Jeremy is dangerous. Outside, Samuel introduces himself to Tracy. He asks her where she plans on taking Jeremy after he is released. He teleports her to the carnival. Samuel says all of the carnies are like her and she should consider the place home.