At the station, Calleigh says they found that Tito fought with Jack and Sean and got their skin under his fingernails. Tom reports the cause of Tito's death was being hit by a car door. Jesse look at photos taken at the limo and figure the killer used his left hand to slam the door into Tito's head.

Jesse and Calleigh give Jack and Sean paperwork to be released. They see that Jack is left handed and figure he killed Tito. They suspect Jack and Sean overpowered and killed Tito when he tried to apprehend them. Jesse tells the suspects they are under arrest. Since they don't remember what happened, they wonder if they killed Charlie.

Tripp tells Jesse he learned Carmel is quitting the strip club. Jesse and Calleigh meet her at the club before she leaves and searches through her bag. Calleigh tells him they don't have a warrant, but Jesse says he doesn't need one. Jesse finds a vial full of scopalmine. Carmel asks them what they want to know in exchange for her freedom. She admits someone paid her to take Charlie to the back where he was kidnapped. Calleigh shows her a picture of Bennet, but she doesn't recognize him. She identifies Kim's father Mr. Hewitt as the kidnapper.

They bring Kim and Hewitt to the station. He confesses he was told about Charlie going to the strip club. He admits he gave Charlie a blank check to pay him to stay away from his daughter. Hewitt admits he kidnapped Charlie and put him on a small boat that was launched to see. Horatio calls a rescue team to look for Charlie. After they pick him up, they deliver Charlie to Horatio at the pier. Charlie and Kim reunite before he is loaded into a ambulance.