JJ briefs the team about their new case. She says two girls, Megan and Bina, and a man named John were killed and had their eyes gouged out. Spencer says the term for this type of killer is called an enucleator. Derek says he chose to work the case since there is a close proximity of time between the murders. Hotch says enucleators are repeat offenders and will most likely strike again.

The team figures that the killer is delusional and was probably institutionalized. They wonder if the unsub was more opportunistic than planned. JJ tells the team that one of the girl's family asked to speak to the team leader. Derek tells Hotch and Spencer to see if the killer targeted John for personal reasons. Garcia calls Spencer and informs him that there are no OKC suspects who liked to gouge eyes. The Oklahoma detective, Brantley, asks why the killer would want the eyes. Spencer explains the eyes might be trophies, but they break down quickly. He says that some killers like to eat the eyes.

Derek and JJ meet with Bina's older sister. She explains because of her Buddhist religion, they are not to allowed to leave. She tells them that her grandma said she saw Bina's ghost looking for her eyes. The sister says they want to cremate her, but they need all of her. Derek says they will try to find her eyes, but they might not be able to recover them. The sister says Bina might be cursed forever.